Seoul Court Sides With Min Hee-jin in 2.5 Billion KRW Suits; Belift Lab & Source Music Vow Appeal
Citing broad freedom of expression in pop culture criticism, the court dismissed claims from both HYBE labels—as well as Min’s 5 billion KRW countersuit.
In a major first-instance ruling in one of K-pop’s highest-profile legal battles, former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin has prevailed against two HYBE subsidiary labels seeking a combined 2.5 billion KRW in damages. On November 13, the Seoul Western District Court’s 12th Civil Division dismissed both Belift Lab’s 2 billion KRW ($1.5 million) suit and Source Music’s 500 million KRW suit against Min, as reported by StarNews and Korea JoongAng Daily.
- Belift Lab Suit (2B KRW): Dismissed; court ruled ILLIT–NewJeans similarity comments were subjective opinions.
- Min Hee-jin Countersuit (5B KRW): Also dismissed; court ruled NewJeans’ brand value belongs to corporations like ADOR, not Min personally.
- Source Music Suit (500M KRW): Dismissed; claims over NewJeans’ casting and debut order were not deemed unlawful falsehoods.
- Next Steps: Both Belift Lab and Source Music announced immediate appeals; a separate criminal referral remains with prosecutors.
1. Why the Court Protected Min’s ILLIT Remarks
At the heart of Belift Lab’s lawsuit were Min’s April 2024 press conference comments alleging that girl group ILLIT imitated NewJeans’ concept. Presiding Judge Kim Jin-young ruled that popular culture is inherently evaluated subjectively and that freedom of expression must be broadly protected unless statements are malicious or severely unreasonable.
“If legal liability were imposed in situations involving similarity controversies, it would hinder criticism of creative works and the healthy development of popular arts,” the court explained. At the same time, the judge rejected Min’s 5 billion KRW countersuit against Belift Lab, noting that NewJeans’ reputation and commercial achievements belong to corporate entities such as ADOR and Source Music rather than Min individually.
2. Source Music’s Claims Over Debut Order Also Dismissed
In the parallel 500 million KRW suit brought by Source Music (agency of LE SSERAFIM), the court likewise found no actionable illegality in Min’s press conference remarks about NewJeans’ casting, trainee treatment, and debut sequence.
Case records showed that HYBE had initially planned to debut NewJeans first before debuting LE SSERAFIM and that Min strongly protested the change, making it difficult to brand her statements as false. The court also viewed her harsher language—such as calling the situation “thugs”—as figurative, evaluative criticism rather than an unlawful personal attack, as detailed by Chosun Ilbo.
Min’s side hailed the outcome as a “common-sense ruling” against excessive legal offensives. Conversely, Belift Lab lamented a verdict suggesting “there are victims but no perpetrators,” while Source Music expressed “sorrow and helplessness”—with both labels confirming immediate appeals, per Maeil Business Newspaper (MK).
3. Criminal Case Still Looms Separately
Despite Min’s civil victory, the broader legal saga is far from over. Alongside the upcoming appeals from Belift Lab and Source Music, a separate criminal investigation remains active: on October 1, Seoul’s Yongsan Police Station referred Min and two former ADOR vice presidents to prosecutors on allegations of defamation and obstruction of business—though Min’s team has stressed that a police referral does not equate to indictment or guilt.
